Commentaries:
Robertson's Word Pictures (NT)
Justified by works (ec ergwn edikaiwqh). First aorist passive indicative of dikaiow (see Galatians and Romans for this verb, to declare righteous, to set right) in a question with ouk expecting an affirmative answer. This is the phrase that is often held to be flatly opposed to Paul's statement in Romans 4:1-5, where Paul pointedly says that it was the faith of Abraham (Romans 4:9) that was reckoned to Abraham for righteousness, not his works. But Paul is talking about the faith of Abraham before his circumcision (James 4:10) as the basis of his being set right with God, which faith is symbolized in the circumcision. James makes plain his meaning also.
In that he offered up Isaac his son upon the altar (anenegkav Isaak ton uion autou epi to qusiasthrion). They use the same words, but they are talking of different acts. James points to the offering (anenegkav second aorist--with first aorist ending--active participle of anaferw) of Isaac on the altar (Genesis 22:16 f.) as proof of the faith that Abraham already had. Paul discusses Abraham's faith as the basis of his justification, that and not his circumcision. There is no contradiction at all between James and Paul. Neither is answering the other. Paul may or may not have seen the Epistle of James, who stood by him loyally in the Conference in Jerusalem (Acts 15; Gal. 2).
Other commentary entries containing this verse:
James 2:23
James 3:4
DISCLAIMER: Church of the Great God (CGG) provides these resources to aid the individual in studying the Bible. However, it is up to the individual to "prove all things, and hold fast to that which is good" (I Thessalonians 5:21). The content of these resources does not necessarily reflect the views of CGG. They are provided for information purposes only.
E-mail this page
